Best Tallow Based Shaving Soap – Top 7 Picks and Reviews 2020

We went through the reviews left by consumers and found the best of the best using our data-backed approach.

Here’s a look at the best Tallow Based Shaving Soap

Bestseller No. 1
Summer Storm by Chiseled Face — Handmade Luxury Shaving Soap — Rich, Thick Lather — Smooth,...
  • THICKER, SLICKER LATHER: Summer Storm Handmade Luxury Shaving Soap will give you the ability to create thicker, richer lather for smoother, more enjoyable shaves, less irritation, and clearer skin.
  • SMELLS GREAT: As if you were caught outside in a rainstorm, our Summer Storm smell blends the best of moist earth, ozone, fresh grass and pine needles, white jasmine, lily of the valley, and more.
  • HANDMADE SOAP: Unlike other shaving soaps that are spit out of a machine, our luxury shaving soaps are carefully crafted by hands that know what shaving is truly about.
  • LONGER LASTING: Our premium shaving soap will last for months - up to 100 shaves - so you don’t have to spend money over and over on inferior soaps or gels that have to be replaced more quickly.
  • MADE IN THE USA: Developed, crafted and packaged from right here in Rancho Cucamonga, California, we pride ourselves on American made products.
SaleBestseller No. 2
Lather & Wood Shaving Soap - Sandalwood - Simply The Best Luxury Shaving Cream - Tallow - Dense...
871 Reviews
Lather & Wood Shaving Soap - Sandalwood - Simply The Best Luxury Shaving Cream - Tallow - Dense...
  • LARGE 4.7oz SHAVE SOAP. A premium tallow based shaving soap for literally pennies a day. Get MONTH-after-MONTH of daily wet shaving satisfaction. Perfect with your favorite shaving brush and safety razor, multi-blade, or straight razor for the more daring type.
  • HAND CRAFTED IN SMALL BATCHES To Insure Highest Quality Possible. As wet shaving enthusiasts we have used all the major and micro brand shaving soaps, and this soap is nothing short of perfection.
  • SOPHISTICATED SANDALWOOD SCENT - This Sandalwood Shaving Soap has a wonderful earthy natural sandalwood scent. Not too strong, but subtlety lingers long after your shave. Pairs Perfectly with Lather & Wood’s Sandalwood Pre-Shave Oil and Sandalwood Aftershave Balm.
  • CUSHY TALLOW BASED SHAVING SOAP - Ingredients like Tallow and Shea Butter produces a ridiculous amount of dense slippery lather. Our lather does not dissipate even after an hour of sitting in your shaving bowl. Amazing Lather, Moisturizing, Slip, and Protection eliminate razor bumps and shaving irritation.
  • TOSS THAT DRUGSTORE SHAVING CREAM IN THE TRASH - Lather & Wood Shaving Co. produces only the finest quality shaving and mens grooming products. Our shaving soap will leaves your skin feeling cool, refreshed, and clean. You'll never touch the commercial stuff again!
Bestseller No. 3
Pine Tar Handmade Luxury Shaving Soap by Chiseled Face — Rich, Thick Lather — Smooth,...
  • THICKER, SLICKER LATHER: Pine Tar Handmade Luxury Shaving Soap will give you the ability to create thicker, richer lather for smoother, more enjoyable shaves, less irritation, and clearer skin.
  • GREAT FOR YOUR SKIN: Pine Tar has been used for years for sensitive or irritated skin.
  • HANDMADE SOAP: Unlike other shaving soaps that are spit out of a machine, our luxury shaving soaps are carefully crafted by hands that know what shaving is truly about.
  • LONGER LASTING: Our premium shaving soap will last for months - up to 100 shaves - so you don’t have to spend money over and over on inferior soaps or gels that have to be replaced more quickly.
  • MADE IN THE USA: Developed, crafted and packaged from right here in Rancho Cucamonga, California, we pride ourselves on American made products.
Bestseller No. 4
TSE for Men Wicked Shaving Soap with Tallow and Shea Butter. Natural Ingredients for Rich Lather and...
  • PREMIUM INGREDIENTS - We partner with sustainable ranchers and growers to source the world's finest ingredients. Natural ingredients like Grass-Fed Tallow, Shea Butter, and White Kaolin Clay protect and moisturize your skin.
  • SUPER RICH LATHER - Our proprietary tallow based formula easily builds a thick, cushiony lather to ensure an exceptionally close and smooth shave.
  • MADE IN THE USA - Hand crafted, small batches, made in Fort Worth, TX USA. Passed down for generations, our signature recipe creates the ultimate comfortable shave.
  • WICKED – Smoldering blend of Black Amber, Clove, Nutmeg, & Musk combine to give this beard oil a deep, complex aroma. A downright sinister union of awesomeness.
  • GUARANTEED – Our goal is to ensure that every customer is 100% happy with their purchase. If for any reason we have not lived up to this claim, please contact us and we will MAKE IT RIGHT.
SaleBestseller No. 5
Premium Shaving Soap for Men by Sir Hare - Barbershop Fragrance - Shave Soap That Smells Great and...
560 Reviews
Premium Shaving Soap for Men by Sir Hare - Barbershop Fragrance - Shave Soap That Smells Great and...
  • Tallow based shaving soap creates a protective lather and lubricates any razor for a smooth and irritation free shave. Leaves you with the closest shave ever.
  • You get a full 4 ounces of shaving soap in an 8 ounce container. That’s enough soap to last for more than 100 shaves. We put it in an 8 ounce container so that you can use it without a shaving bowl, and it saves you from making a mess.
  • Each Shaving Soap is handcrafted and hand poured into the containers, leaving an uneven surface. This is perfectly normal and results in a high quality product made especially for you. Hand Made and hand poured in the U.S. in small batches for the best quality. Great for all skin types including sensitive skin. Reduced friction helps reduces chance for razor bumps or rashes while shaving
  • Old fashioned barbershop scent that is Fresh and Clean with hints of Bergamot, Oakmoss, and Cedarwood.
  • Shaving should be an experience and not a chore. You should UPGRADE your shave today and buy with confidence with our no hassle money back guarantee. Support our small family business by clicking on the add to cart up and to the right and you'll be glad you did. Sir Hare prides itself on quality mens care.
Bestseller No. 6
Shaving Soap WSP Formula T (Barbershop) 4.7 Oz Made with Shea Butter & Tallow
  • Building off the success of our vegan Rustic Shaving Soap, we set out to create the best tallow based shave soap possible. We wanted an easy to lather soap with great cushion & moisturizing properties with excelling glide. You be the judge, but we think we nailed it with Formula T.
  • Formulated with tallow & shea butter for extra cushion, moisture, & a superior post shave feel.
  • Made in America at our food grade workshop in Chandler, AZ with moisturizing Tallow & Shea Butter for the perfect shave. Free of synthetic dyes & preservatives. The full list of natural ingredients includes: stearic acid, water, tallow, coconut oil, potassium hydroxide, glycerin, butyrospermum parkii (Shea butter), fragrance, & sodium hydroxide. Free of synthetic dyes & preservatives.
  • Formula T is extremely dense. Our long lasting concentrated soap will last you from 150 up to 350 shaves. 135 grams, 4.7 ounces by weight. The secret is the long curing process. We let the soap cure for as long as it takes to remove any excess water, so all you're buying is soap; not water.
  • Wide mouth tin makes loading & storage easy.
Bestseller No. 7
Triple Milled Tallow Shaving Soap for Men | Duc de Santal Wet Shave Soap Fragrance | Made by Skilled...
  • REFINED GENTLEMEN SCENT : Sit back and savour the musky, woody aromas that form part of this warm and comforting scent. Sophistication in every sense of the word, Duc de Santal defines notability and a sense of good taste and high-class styling of the upper echelons of society.
  • LONG LASTING LATHER, CUSHIONING AND GLIDE. Load and lather with ease for an amazing shave. It’s not diluted with water as a shaving cream and super easy to load on the brush.
  • OLD FASHIONED WET SHAVE, SMOOTH FEELING - back to the basics with this traditional long lasting lather and ultra glide shaving soap.
  • PREVENTS RAZOR BURN AND DRY SKIN | FOR SENSITIVE SKIN - the high-quality lather shaving cream lubricates and provides a superior glide.
  • HANDCRAFTED BY SKILLED ARTISANS - made by human hands in small batches at Henri et Victoria’s shop to ensure premium quality and maximum freshness.