Best Bagel Toppings

We went over the reviews left by consumers and found the best of the best using data-driven technology.

Here’s a look at the best Bagel Toppings

Bestseller No. 1
McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning, 21 oz - One 21 Ounce Container of Everything Bagel...
  • Burst of Flavor: McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning features an enticing mix of poppy seed, sesame seed, garlic, onion and salt for a balanced burst of flavor and striking texture
  • Sourced for Chefs: Blended especially for chefs, McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning is made with crunchy, eye-catching bits of authentic ingredients, conveniently preblended for optimal consistency
  • Natural Ingredients: This everything bagel seasoning is kosher and includes no added MSG, so you can create dishes with a perfectly balanced flavor all your customers can enjoy
  • Buy in Bulk: McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning comes in large 21-ounce plastic containers ideal for bulk buying and professional use; when you buy in bulk, you always have the amount of seasoning you need to customize recipes on the spot
  • Menu Versatility: You can use everything bagel seasoning to enhance recipes beyond bagels; try McCormick Culinary Everything Bagel Seasoning in dressings, avocado toast, hummus and par-baked breads for a familiar flavor your patrons love
SaleBestseller No. 2
King Arthur, Everything Bagel Topping, Certified Kosher, 8 Ounces
80 Reviews
King Arthur, Everything Bagel Topping, Certified Kosher, 8 Ounces
  • If you've got the loaf to be topped - we've got the seeds! Includes poppy and sesame seeds, dried onion, garlic, and salt. 8-ounce reusable jar
  • This topping is great for bagels, bread and salt sticks! All this goodness is available in a convenient reusable plastic jar
  • King Arthur Everything Bagel Topping is Certified Kosher and offered in a convenient reusable or recyclable jar
  • King Arthur Baking Company is a 100% Employee-Owned Company and a founding B Corporation
  • We are King Arthur Baking Company. Our name and logo reflect who we've always been and always will be: bakers who are committed to spreading the simple joy of baking
Bestseller No. 3
Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend Original XL 10 Ounce Jar. Delicious Blend of Sea Salt and Spices...
  • FLAVOR PACKED EVERYTHING BAGEL SEASONING: Not all everything bagel seasonings are created equal. SPQR Seasonings everything but the bagel sesame seasoning mix has been sourced using only the finest ingredients. California roasted garlic, minced dried onion, sea salt flakes, black and natural roasted sesame seeds for a tasty crunch are just a few of the zesty flavors in this seasoned salt spice mix. This XL original everything bagel spice shaker is a staple for every kitchen pantry.
  • KETO, WEIGHT WATCHERS, ENDLESSLY DIET FRIENDLY: With only 5 calories per serving and virtually no fat, you get A LOT of flavor for not a lot of calories. Try this on all of your bland diet foods like egg whites, grilled chicken, lean steak, avocado toast, in salads, on bagels, you name it and this everything bagel sesame seasoning blend will make your mouth water. There isn't a diet that this spice will not complement.
  • UNMATCHED VALUE IN EVERY BOTTLE: With this 10 oz spice shaker from SPQR Seasonings, you get up to 5x the high quality ingredients over the store bought competitors for a price that won't hurt your wallet. This kitchen staple will last meal after meal whether for personal use or spicing up the life of your entire family. Our customers are stunned at how far one 10oz bottle gets them, bulk buy everything bagel seasoning is the only way to do everything bagel seasoning.
  • ALL PURPOSE SEASONING: Whether you are making homemade bagels to rival the local bagel shop, or you're looking for a seasoned salt mix to add flavor to your food, SPQR Seasonings everything bagel sesame seasoning blend will have your guests guessing what you did to create such a flavorful experience. Use it as a dry rub for meats, salmon, fish, or use it in your favorite dip, on buttered popcorn, sandwiches, fries, pizza, the possibilities are endless.
  • UNIQUE & FUN GIFT IDEA: From our witty quotes on the side of the label to the endless flavor blast inside the bottle, this everything bagel sesame seasoning spice mix is a stellar choice for any house warming gift, bridal favor, mothers & fathers day present or a "just because" gift for a loved one. Drop the flowers, grab the spice shaker and impress the best of them!
SaleBestseller No. 4
Trader Joe's Everything but the Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend 2.3 oz, Pack of 1
1,662 Reviews
Trader Joe's Everything but the Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend 2.3 oz, Pack of 1
  • Pack of 1 - 2. 3 ounce glass shaker
  • Ingredients: sesame seeds, sea salt flakes, dried minced garlic, dried minced onion, black sesame seeds, poppy seeds
  • 2. 3-Ounce glass shaker
SaleBestseller No. 5
Trader Joe's Everything but The Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend (Pack of 2)
789 Reviews
Trader Joe's Everything but The Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend (Pack of 2)
  • Pack of 2 bottles - 2.3 ounce each
  • Ingredients: sesame seeds, sea salt flakes, dried minced garlic, dried minced onion, black sesame seeds, poppy seeds
  • 2.3-Ounce glass shaker
Bestseller No. 6
The Spice Lab Everything Bagel Seasoning – 4.6 oz Shaker Jar - Premium Gourmet PALEO and KETO...
  • EVERYTHING BUT THE BAGEL: The happy accident (or mysterious experiment?) that took bagels to the next level in the 1980s is now an everything savory blend distinguished by extra crunchy Hudson Valley Salt and a hint of chili spice. A pantry staple, it makes a great gift for gourmet chefs and beginners alike.
  • FLAVOR & USE: This chef-crafted, savory blend with a subtle kick is the perfect topping for buttered popcorn and avocado toast. Sprinkle it on soft-boiled eggs. Let it boost your barley and rock your risotto. Best used as a finishing spice but try mixing it into frittata ingredients before baking for added, flavorsome goodness.
  • PREMIUM ALL NATURAL INGREDIENTS: Our tasty blend combines crunchy Hudson Valley salt, sesame seeds, dried onion and garlic, poppy seeds and chili flakes.
  • QUALITY: Packed in an SQF-certified facility in the USA, this all natural blend is non GMO, kosher and gluten free.
  • VALUES: We source the highest quality spices, hire a diverse workforce and cultivate a friendly, supportive and safe work environment that reflects our brand.
Bestseller No. 7
Castle Foods Everything Bagel Seasoning, 11 oz
  • FLAVORFUL AND AROMATIC: Everything bagel seasoning is the ideal seasoning blend for your meal with its slightly pungent scent and wholesome taste
  • SEASONING BLENDS FOR ALL OCCASIONS: Everything Bagel Seasoning is a brilliant blend that works for everything, from healthy snacks to main dishes.; You could rub it on meats, sprinkle it on soups or pair it with sandwiches for smiles around the dinner table
  • A HEALTHY CHOICE: For tantalizing flavors that last a lifetime, this mixture of sesame and poppy seeds with garlic, onion and red pepper, these spice blends are bound to make your food nutritious
  • PACKED SPICES AND SEASONING: Castle provides sustainable products; Coming in a 11 ounce bottle, it is filled by weight and maintains a standard quality at every stage
  • FAMILY KITCHEN: Providing flavourful punch to all your dishes since 1948, Castle products come from organic herb and spice farms, and are a mainstay in kitchens for many generations